Same Sex Marriage Should be Legalized Essay example
2339 Words10 Pages
Every little girl dreams of her wedding day, and many can even be seen dressing up, putting pillow cases on their heads and pretending that they are actually walking down that long aisle towards the one they love. As these little girls grow up, some of them, as well as some little boys . who may not play dress up, but have equal aspirations of marriage when they grow up . will be faced with the harsh reality that this illustrious day may never come to pass for them. The reason is not that they will be unable to find someone with whom they want to spend their lives, but that whom they have chosen is unacceptable to society because they happen to be of the same sex. Evidence today shows that homosexuality is not a choice,…show more content…
For example, in 1968, when the law was passed, 72% of the population in the United
States disapproved of interracial marriage (Sullivan XXV). In fact, "hostility to same-sex marriage in 2004 is markedly less profound than hostility to interracial marriage was in
1968." Only about 60% of Americans are presently against legalizing same-sex unions, according to most polls (Sullivan XXVI). Hopefully, the U.S. government will realize that denying marriage to homosexuals is just as discriminatory as denying marriage to interracial couples in the past.
In addition to the denial of civil rights, the illegality of same-sex marriage also denies a multitude of more tangible benefits to homosexual couples. According to Nancy
Wilson, vice-moderator of the Universal Fellowship of Metropolitan Community
Churches, there are at least 200 "legal rights" that heterosexual married couples receive, which are not given to homosexual couples (Clash Over Gay Marriage 1996 para 5). The estimate of the U.S. General Accounting office is more generous, stating that, "more than
1,000 special benefits are automatically provided to heterosexual married couples simply because they are married. One example is that same-sex partners do not get to share in the benefits that married couples receive through the ability to file jointly on their income
Gay marriage is also referred to as same sex marriage. Same sex relationships occur when men and women are attracted to someone of the same gender as themselves. According to many opponents, gay marriages can be described as more of the abandonment of gender distinctions because one cannot have same sex marriage while still believing that gender is relevant. For that reason, same gender getting married denies the obvious purpose of marriage between a man and woman which is procreation. This research will analyze the arguments for and against gay marriages and the religious view of same sex marriages.
Denying same sex couples the legal rights to get married could mean denial of basic rights to enjoy the human benefits. On the other hand, if gay marriages are granted the legal rights this might be a threat to the stability of the traditional meaning of family. Many people in the society view gays and lesbians as immoral people since traditional belief of a marriage in the society is between one man and woman. Proponents and gays movement fight for legal right to marriage in order to ensure that all citizens enjoy full human rights. Many religions also view same sex marriages as immoral and if gays and lesbians are legalized the church would be offended since marriage is an institution supposed to be holy and ordained by God. For that reason allowing same sex marriage means violation of the sanctity of marriage.
There exists harmful consequences if gay and lesbian couples are not recognized in the society. The main challenges same sex marriages face include inability to participate in medical decisions that involve their partner who are dying, lack of right to own common property and exclusion from employment benefits. Opponents also fear that if gay marriages are recognized the society is more likely to accept same sex relationships as moral. The traditional definition of marriage is valuable and the society should define it as the only marriage and legitimize it. Gay marriages are the eventual rejection of objective reality where an environment of going against the norm is created therefore; it is upon the government to decide whether to legalize this marriages or not (Larocque 87).
Arguments for Same Sex Marriages
In Canada same sex marriages is legal. Advocates of gay marriages describe marriage between a man and a woman as a weakened institution that divides the society by sex. On the other hand, they sum up same sex marriages as private, intimate and emotional relationship where two people unite for their own personal reasons in order to enhance their personal well-up.
Socially many people think that gay marriages are not acceptable therefore the couples should not have the right to get married. In some countries such as Canada, there is dramatic progress to acknowledge the rights of gays and lesbians. Court battles have been filed and to some extent gays and lesbians have succeeded in obtaining some degree of social recognition (Staver 5). The gay movement argument for same sex marriage is basically founded on the norm of formal equality. They argue that the state needs to accord the gays the same legal options as other different sex couples enjoy. This includes the right and duties required in civil marriage. Economic benefits that the proponents of gay marriages cite include increased revenue as a result of additional marriages through marriage taxes (Stockland 134).
Arguments Against Same Sex Marriages
For a long time the culture of men and women marrying each other in the society has been established globally. Two men or women marrying therefore have resulted to a controversy where people have differing opinions. Same sex marriages cannot have children. The debate for this issue of same sex marriage has existed for many years and a gay right movement was established in America during the 1960s. Getting married is a decision which is personal and private. The controversy brought by gay marriages includes changing the norm of marriage and challenges in existing laws and religious traditions. Many religions in the world object to the issue of gay marriages on the grounds of morality. Churches base on their beliefs of what is wrong or right on scriptures which are holy writings. The church believes that allowing the gay couples to adopt children would be an injustice as the children will lack the proper moral upbringing.
The priorities of the gay’s right movement include combating discrimination in the workplace and securing the right to serve in the military as well as adopting children. Opponents of gay marriages cite the increased social costs such as healthcare thus affecting the economy. Those against this kind of marriage think that same sex couples should not be allowed to adopt children. The opponents are generally concerned about the harmful effect gay marriages would have on the society in case of legalization. They believe that the family institution is protected through heterosexual marriage whose main aim is to procreate. They further believe that marriage would no longer have the same meaning if homosexual couples find alternative methods of having children (Nagle 31).
Should Gay Marriage be Legalized?
First, every person has a right to exercise and acquire freedom and equality as a basic law. In many countries such as the United States same sex marriages are outlawed although some government leaders insist on legalizing the gay marriages because they believe in the principle of equality. The church opposes same sex marriage since they believe that the bible instructs how Christians should properly live. The church believes that God wants marriage which is between a man and a woman. The church is against the legalization of gay marriages as they believe many people may choose to live homosexually thus promoting it as acceptable in the society. According to the church, allowing the gay couples to adopt children would be an injustice as the children will lack the proper moral upbringing. If gay marriage was legalized they can have the same rights as heterosexuals in terms of adoption and medical rights (Lopez 46).
In conclusion, issue of same sex marriage has raised many debates for many years. Same sex marriages have some disadvantages while on the other hand, it can mean denial of basic rights to enjoy the human benefits. First, every person has a right to exercise and acquire freedom and equality as a basic law. Same sex marriages are outlawed in many countries such as the United States although some government leaders insist on legalizing the gay marriages because they believe in the principle of equality. Many churches oppose same sex marriage and believe that God wants marriage to be between a man and a woman. As a result, the church is against the legalization of gay marriages because it can be viewed by the society as promoting homosexually in the society. According to the church, allowing the gay couples to adopt children would be an injustice as the children will lack the proper moral upbringing.
Gay marriages can be granted the legal rights which mean a threat to the stability of the traditional meaning of family. Gays and lesbians can also be granted the rights to legal marriage in order to ensure that all citizens enjoy full human rights. Therefore, if gay marriage is legalized they can have the same rights as heterosexuals in terms of adoption and medical rights (Lopez 46). On the other hand, the religions would be offended since marriage is an institution supposed to be holy and ordained by God if gays and lesbians are legalized. Therefore, by allowing same sex marriage sanctity of marriage would be violated. If gay marriages are not legally recognized the harmful consequences the couples would face include inability to participate in medical decisions that involve their partner who are dying, lack of right to own common property and exclusion from employment benefits. Opponents also fear that if gay marriages are recognized the society is more likely to accept same sex relationships as moral. The traditional definition of marriage is valuable and the society should define it as the only marriage and legitimize it. As a result, gay marriages are the eventual rejection of objective reality where an environment of going against the norm is created (Larocque 87).